You are not logged in.
Is there a way to easily install only free software in Arch Linux? Something like Debian's free non-free repo's or Gentoo's ACCEPT_LICENSE in make.conf?
Offline
No. You could probably hack something together using the license information (for example, ignore all packages with 'custom' in the License field). Of course, there are even some packages in 'base' which have custom licenses....
Allan-Volunteer on the (topic being discussed) mailn lists. You never get the people who matters attention on the forums.
jasonwryan-Installing Arch is a measure of your literacy. Maintaining Arch is a measure of your diligence. Contributing to Arch is a measure of your competence.
Griemak-Bleeding edge, not bleeding flat. Edge denotes falls will occur from time to time. Bring your own parachute.
Offline
You can check a package's license with 'pacman -Si <package>'.
Sakura:-
Mobo: MSI MAG X570S TORPEDO MAX // Processor: AMD Ryzen 9 5950X @4.9GHz // GFX: AMD Radeon RX 5700 XT // RAM: 32GB (4x 8GB) Corsair DDR4 (@ 3000MHz) // Storage: 1x 3TB HDD, 6x 1TB SSD, 2x 120GB SSD, 1x 275GB M2 SSD
Making lemonade from lemons since 2015.
Offline
There is Parabola, the free-only fork
https://wiki.archlinux.org/index.php/Ar … NU.2FLinux
Offline
Offline
If you have a proprietary device of some kind on your machinery, even with a libre collection, that device would still prevent you from having a GNU recommended free system. I used a stock Arch kernel and a libre kernel for the same device. I had to use some solution provided by the manufacturer originally that has been developed by the open source community and it didn't work as good as the stock Arch kernel. In fact it had a tendency to leave the equipment in an unpredictable state. Your mileage may vary.
Parabola has instructions on how to install it from within Arch, and then it uses its' repos, and then finally removes anything that doesn't have a libre package.
I may have to CONSOLE you about your usage of ridiculously easy graphical interfaces...
Look ma, no mouse.
Offline
If you have a proprietary device of some kind on your machinery, even with a libre collection, that device would still prevent you from having a GNU recommended free system.
I'm confused. What is a "proprietary device"? Why would it prevent me from using only software that is free, as defined by the Free Software Foundation?
A person who chooses to use only free software will either proactively select hardware this compatible with free software or choose not to use that hardware at all.
Offline
Thanks for all the tips! Good to know you can easily check a package license with pacman. I rather have a system wide setting though. Parabola looks promising, unfortunately I do need some non-free software, nvidia driver to be precise. An implementation of bug #6510 would be ideal. Unfortunately is has been open for 5 years now. I hope it's get implemented some day :-)
Last edited by Kasumi_Ninja (2012-10-31 14:33:57)
Offline
@drcouzelis, I think what nomorewindows means is that you may have hardware that requires a proprietary module/driver. So if that is the case, one must decide between poor/no functionality with the native kernel module, or choose to install a proprietary licensed module to gain that functioanlity. For instance, I believe broadcom wifi is this way (though I may be wrong as it has been a while since I have used a broadcom device). Also, nvidia video cards are nother example. Fortunately the nvidia drivers are getting better everyday, but the blob is purported to be far superior, though it is closed source. I think too that there is some hardware that does not work well with the open source nvidia module, and instead requires closed source to really function at all.
Offline
@drcouzelis, I think what nomorewindows means is that you may have hardware that requires a proprietary module/driver. So if that is the case, one must decide between poor/no functionality with the native kernel module, or choose to install a proprietary licensed module to gain that functioanlity. For instance, I believe broadcom wifi is this way (though I may be wrong as it has been a while since I have used a broadcom device). Also, nvidia video cards are nother example. Fortunately the nvidia drivers are getting better everyday, but the blob is purported to be far superior, though it is closed source. I think too that there is some hardware that does not work well with the open source nvidia module, and instead requires closed source to really function at all.
Yes, that's the case. I actually use Parabola on my laptop but I cannot use its Intel wifi card because of its binary blob. I don't mind though since I just use it as a desktop replacement that's connected via eth0.
Offline
Thanks for all the tips! Good to know you can easily check a package license with pacman. I rather have a system wide setting though. Parabola looks promising, unfortunately I do need some non-free software, nvidia driver to be precise. An implementation of bug #6510 would be ideal. Unfortunately is has been open for 5 years now. I hope it's get implemented some day :-)
Nothing's really stopping you from installing non-free software in Parabola; it just makes a point not even to suggest the existence of such software.
"Where there's a will, there's a way."
Last edited by jakobcreutzfeldt (2012-10-31 14:41:50)
Offline
@jakobcreutzfeldt, wow I never realized the intel firmware was non-free. I guesss I just never really thought about it. But Intel is so good with their contributions to open-source, that I just kind of assumed the firmware must be open too. Oh well, I still love my Intel Centrino Advanced-N 6235 since it replaced a Realtek running on the infamous rtl8192ce module. Unfortunately, I have seen specs of sysetm76 machines that indictate they ship with this same realtek card. Hopefully this has been changed by now.
Offline
Also, nvidia video cards are nother example. Fortunately the nvidia drivers are getting better everyday, but the blob is purported to be far superior, though it is closed source.
Also, lest there's any confusion, there are no free software drivers for any modern Nvidia and Radeon video cards, also for many new Intel video cards, that will provide accelerated graphics. You can have good 2D support, including native resolutions, but not accelerated (3D) graphics. You can have accelerated graphics using only open source software but not with only free software.
...I'd love for someone to prove me wrong, but I'm pretty sure that's still true in 2012. ![]()
Edit: Now I'm curious about nouveau... I'm still researching it.
Edit: I'm not really correct (AKA I'm wrong), please see below. ![]()
Last edited by drcouzelis (2012-10-31 15:50:59)
Offline
Instead of grepping pacman's output, you can use expac:
expac "%n %L" -S pacman xorg-server unzip | column -t
pacman GPL
xorg-server custom
unzip customOffline
I was inder the impression that there was no non-open Intel driver. The i915 is included in the kernel, so it is definitely gpl2, no?
Edit: From the Arch Wiki Intel page:
Since Intel provides and supports open source drivers, Intel graphics are now essentially plug-and-play.Edit2:This is why Intel hardware is typically recommended for Linux, so long as the use does not intend to do graphics heavy work.
Edit3: This is why I chose an Intel based machine. I figured compatibility would be super simple. When it comes to functional hardware, I am certainly not looking for a challenge.
Last edited by WonderWoofy (2012-10-31 15:43:16)
Offline
I was inder the impression that there was no non-open Intel driver. The i915 is included in the kernel, so it is definitely gpl2, no?
This thread is about free software. The opposite of free software is non-free software.
I know that the "radeon" driver that comes with the kernel is non-free software, as can be seen here: http://git.kernel.org/?p=linux/kernel/g … 19;hb=HEAD
I shouldn't have spoken about Intel video cards since I'm not educated about them. What I should have said was that there's no free software drivers that provide accelerated graphics for desktop / PCIe video cards.
...that said, I still can't find definitive information about the nouveau drivers. As far as I understand (which is very little), they used to be non-free, but the non-free parts have been removed, but they don't have accelerated graphics support... but they do? ![]()
Offline
3D with nouveau has gotten much better recently - I get a properly rendered openarena now, instead of a bunch of colored polygons ;P but it's still not nearly as good as nvidia.
Offline
Unfortunately, I have seen specs of sysetm76 machines that indictate they ship with this same realtek card. Hopefully this has been changed by now.
I don't want to derail the thread too much but my laptop is a System76 from this year and the only wi-fi options available were for Intel.
Anyway, the Intel wireless driver is open source but it requires a binary firmware blob. Personally I don't understand why it needs to be distributed as firmware then and not just flashed onto the card once and for all. Their argument for the binary blob is that certain aspects of a wi-fi card, such as the radio frequencies on which it operates, should not be open to tinkering because they would void the various approvals that the device receives (FCC and such, if I remember correctly); I would argue that if it shouldn't be open for tinkering and, indeed, it should never be changed, it should just be permanently flashed onto the card. But, I must confess general ignorance about the inner workings of wi-fi cards.
I think the only other device on my laptop that I can't use due to using linux-libre is the SD card reader but I don't really care about that, so I haven't even checked.
Offline
Supposedly cheaper for to load the firmware into firmware memory each time instead of having it permanently placed into hardware. Now it requires two devices, the hard drive to pull the firmware from and the device itself.
I may have to CONSOLE you about your usage of ridiculously easy graphical interfaces...
Look ma, no mouse.
Offline
another example is the iwlwifi, is gpl but load nonfree firmware
how you see the driver can be gpl but not the firmware loaded
Lenovo ThinkPad L420 modified
:: Intel i7 2560QM :: 8 GB RAM :: SSD 256 GB ::
:: DVD read+Writter :: 3 USB 3.0 Expresa Card ::
:: a Favulous 1 mins lasting Io-Li battery ::cry::
Offline
Ii have found a solution parabola uses a your-freeom package to block all non-free software packages. I think I can use the PKGBUILD for Arch :-)
Offline
Ii have found a solution parabola uses a your-freeom package to block all non-free software packages. I think I can use the PKGBUILD for Arch :-)
That's one of the last steps to completing the installation for parabola. Not sure why you'd want to make a new PKGBUILD for something that already exists.
I may have to CONSOLE you about your usage of ridiculously easy graphical interfaces...
Look ma, no mouse.
Offline
Correct me if I'm wrong, but I'm under the impression that the opposite of free software is paid or "commercial" software.
And I don't think that there's anything like that (e.g. shareware) in [core], [extra] or [community]. Perhaps you're referring to open source software? In that case, keep in mind that all PDF readers on Linux are crappy. The only exception would be acroread from the AUR, but it's not getting much love either (yes, this is from August): http://j00ru.vexillium.org/?p=1175
VirtualBox is open source, but the extension pack required for USB access is not. Other examples are flashplugin and skype.
Last edited by DSpider (2012-11-01 14:54:30)
I have made a personal commitment not to reply in topics that start with a lowercase letter. Proper grammar and punctuation is a sign of respect, and if you do not show any, you will NOT receive any help (at least not from me).
Offline
Correct me if I'm wrong, but I'm under the impression that the opposite of free software is paid or "commercial" software.
For the purposes of this discussion, you're wrong. In this case, free has nothing to do with money, but with what you're allowed to do with it.
Offline
Kasumi_Ninja wrote:Ii have found a solution parabola uses a your-freeom package to block all non-free software packages. I think I can use the PKGBUILD for Arch :-)
That's one of the last steps to completing the installation for parabola. Not sure why you'd want to make a new PKGBUILD for something that already exists.
It doesn't exist for Arch yet. Moreover I have less strict definition of Free Software, I would include firefox for example.
Offline