You are not logged in.
I had this bug some times ago, that got solved after an update of Plymouth. The bug, unfortunately, reappeared a short time after. However, i noticed that xfpanel loaded the right theme and after the wrong theme without icons. A killall gnome-settings-daemon gave me the previous panel with no icons, sadly, but a new login (with gnome-settings-daemon unchecked on load and xfsettingsd checked) gave me the right theme.
In short, it was gnome-settings-daemon running after xfsettingsd that changed the look, so if you have the same problem just uncheck it from load in xfce4-session-settings / automatic start, and make sure to have xfsettingsd checked.
Offline