You are not logged in.

#1 2013-10-06 12:53:14

nyquist
Member
Registered: 2013-10-06
Posts: 7

TV - Virtual machine, Multiseat or SmatTV

Hi to all,

in the next few weeks I'm going to buy a TV and a new PC. I don't have Satellite or Cable TV so I'm using services like Netflix, Hulu.. In the moment I'm watching everything on my laptop, but after I buy a TV I want to watch this online streaming services also on my new TV. Here is a list of features I want for my new PC/TV setup:

1. Watching Hulu, Netflix, Youtube on TV
2. Watching movies saved on my PC-s HDD on the TV
3. Surfing the web from my TV (facebook, reading news portals..)

The important thing is that I want that 2 users can use the PC and TV at the same time, but doing different things.
Example: User 1 is on facebook on the TV while User 2 is writing something in Libreoffice on the PC.

As I see the situation I have 3 ways to accomplish that:

1. Buy a SmartTV which has native apps for Netflix, Youtube, and a web browser. I saw that I can also stream movies from my PC to a SmartTV.
    Questions about this option: How good are this native apps? How good is the web browser in smart TVs. Does it support flash? If some has a SmartTV and is using features like netflix, please give me some feedback. Thanks.

2. Connect the TV with a HDMI cable to my PC. Setup a VM, and run it in full screen mode on the TV. Set the options in VirtualBox so that it captures only actions from one mose and one keyboard, while the other mouse and keyboard are used in the native OS (like described in this link).
   Question about this option: Are there performance issues while playing HD movies in the Virtual machine? How good is the setup described in the link above (if some one is using it, please give some feedback, Thanks)?

3. Setup multiseat with TV connected as the second monitor.
   Questions: The new PC will have a i5 (maybe i7). Can I setup multiseat so that I connect one monitor to use the i5 graphics while connecting the TV to a PCIexpress graphic card, or do I need two graphic cards? I am using the awesome WM with no DE. I don't know how good a  multiseat setup is working with the awesome WM. If some one has a multiseat setup while using awesome please give me some feedback about possible problems. Thanks.

The hardware of the new PC will be something like:
CPU: i5/i7
SDD: 120GB
HDD: 1 TB
GPU: Some graphic card - only if i'll be using multiseat. I dont play games or do video editing, so i really don't need one.
RAM: 8GB

Which of thease setups do you think would be the best for the feauters that I described above.

Offline

#2 2013-10-06 13:24:15

nomorewindows
Member
Registered: 2010-04-03
Posts: 3,548

Re: TV - Virtual machine, Multiseat or SmatTV

Just plug your computer into the TV for the monitor.  Then run mythtv to pick up TV through a TV tuner connected to the computer.  It can be run on the TV connected through the computer at the same time.  For everything else, there's ssh.


I may have to CONSOLE you about your usage of ridiculously easy graphical interfaces...
Look ma, no mouse.

Offline

#3 2013-10-06 16:22:56

nyquist
Member
Registered: 2013-10-06
Posts: 7

Re: TV - Virtual machine, Multiseat or SmatTV

nomorewindows wrote:

Just plug your computer into the TV for the monitor.  Then run mythtv to pick up TV through a TV tuner connected to the computer.  It can be run on the TV connected through the computer at the same time.  For everything else, there's ssh.

I am not quite sure I understand the setup you explained. For what would I need a TV turner if I only watch series and movies via the net, and from where should I ssh into my PC if I only have one PC? Please explain it a little more.

Offline

#4 2013-10-06 21:19:58

nomorewindows
Member
Registered: 2010-04-03
Posts: 3,548

Re: TV - Virtual machine, Multiseat or SmatTV

Multiseat...multiseat...I run awesome on my laptop's main panel, and do an extended desktop onto the external monitor.  You need to find out what your external video will drive upto resolution wise.  I think you can start a separate session on each monitor.  If the resolutions differ too much, this would be recommended.  If you are using two mice and two keyboards (most likely USB), X can probably do that.


I may have to CONSOLE you about your usage of ridiculously easy graphical interfaces...
Look ma, no mouse.

Offline

#5 2013-10-06 22:13:20

Steef435
Member
Registered: 2013-08-29
Posts: 577
Website

Re: TV - Virtual machine, Multiseat or SmatTV

My experience with smart tvs is that they don't have enough apps, the browser is terrible(also no flash, but one could call that less terribleness) and not enough codecs. And even if the apps were great you're still controlling it with a remote control(optional wireless keyboard). It feels like a smartphone with a remote control instead of a finger. I wouldn't use facebook on it. Also, they're not easily hackable smile

I've no experience with running two X servers and let them both work with different input hardware but I guess it's possible. I don't think it requires two GPUs to render two X sessions. Running multiple X sessions is quite normal I believe.

Offline

#6 2013-10-14 13:53:16

MisterAnderson
Member
Registered: 2011-09-04
Posts: 285

Re: TV - Virtual machine, Multiseat or SmatTV

Can't give any info here about Smart TV apps. Australia don't get anything like netflix or hulu or whatever. I can say though your best bet would probably be biting the bullet and getting a second PC for the TV, because everything I've read about multiseat and multiple X11 screens make it look almost impossible, and no fun at all to set up.

You can always try the raspberry pi for the TV, most people seem to have a lot of success with it and I even think Arch's ARM fork works on it, plus it's like $35 or something ridiculously cheap.


D:

Offline

Board footer

Powered by FluxBB