Arch Linux

patchouli

Member

Registered: 2024-09-18

Posts: 22

[SOLVED] Disabling GSP firmware on nvidia-open

Using nvidia-open (565) on RTX 4090, I don’t seem to be able to disable the GSP firmware via the nvidia.NVreg_EnableGpuFirmware=0 kernel parameter. Adding the option to modprobe.d and rebuilding initramfs doesn’t help either.

Using KMS by adding the nvidia modules to the mkinitpcio config.

$ nvidia-smi -q | grep GSP
GSP Firmware Version                  : 565.57.0

Reports the current driver version rather than “N/A” as it should according to the NVIDIA documentation: https://download.nvidia.com/XFree86/Lin … E/gsp.html

Advice appreciated.

Last edited by patchouli (2024-11-20 06:30:38)

Scimmia

Fellow

Registered: 2012-09-01

Posts: 12,550

Re: [SOLVED] Disabling GSP firmware on nvidia-open

yeah, you can't do that.

GollyGeeWizz

Member

From: Port Charlotte, FL

Registered: 2017-02-01

Posts: 2

Re: [SOLVED] Disabling GSP firmware on nvidia-open

You cannot disable GSP firmware on the nvidia-open driver. I cannot find the official comment again but right now one of the limitations of the nvidia-open and nvidia-open-dkms driver is the inability to disable the GSP firmware. If you wish to do that you have to use the proprietary nvidia or nvidia-dkms driver for now.

patchouli

Member

Registered: 2024-09-18

Posts: 22

Re: [SOLVED] Disabling GSP firmware on nvidia-open

You cannot disable GSP firmware on the nvidia-open driver. I cannot find the official comment again but right now one of the limitations of the nvidia-open and nvidia-open-dkms driver is the inability to disable the GSP firmware. If you wish to do that you have to use the proprietary nvidia or nvidia-dkms driver for now.

That seems to be right. I moved on to the proprietary kernel modules as KDE’s KWin compositor struggles to compose at my screen’s refresh rate (2560x1440 240Hz) as long the as the GSP firmware is enabled, on my RTX 4090.

I hope they’ll fix the issue with their implementation somewhat soon so that I can start using nvidia-open again.

Marked as solved, and thanks for the advice.

Last edited by patchouli (2024-11-20 06:33:32)

V1del

Forum Moderator

Registered: 2012-10-16

Posts: 24,223

Re: [SOLVED] Disabling GSP firmware on nvidia-open

GSP firmware is the main reason they can do a open nvidia module in the first place. You can offload the proprietary bits into the firmware that you're not allowed to redistribute as open source, which is why it's a hard requirement (before you cry murder, the same happens with the respective firmware blobs for amdgpu/i915)

RyLoS78

Member

Registered: 2024-01-08

Posts: 7

Re: [SOLVED] Disabling GSP firmware on nvidia-open

You cannot disable GSP firmware on the nvidia-open driver. I cannot find the official comment again but right now one of the limitations of the nvidia-open and nvidia-open-dkms driver is the inability to disable the GSP firmware. If you wish to do that you have to use the proprietary nvidia or nvidia-dkms driver for now.

That seems to be right. I moved on to the proprietary kernel modules as KDE’s KWin compositor struggles to compose at my screen’s refresh rate (2560x1440 240Hz) as long the as the GSP firmware is enabled, on my RTX 4090.

I hope they’ll fix the issue with their implementation somewhat soon so that I can start using nvidia-open again.

Marked as solved, and thanks for the advice.

I just did the same on my 3070 but wayland is still not smooth as X11 for me (180hz monitor here), are you using wayland or X11?