You are not logged in.
Which one is the best option if you're looking for the most Gnome2-like experience? Pretty effects and such would be nice as well, but Gnome Shell just doesn't cut it for me. I prefer the old Gnome 2, and I know many here do as well. Also, what about MATE and MGSE? Are they stable, functional, pretty, lightweight, etc? Any help is much appretiated ![]()
Offline
I run Gnome 3.4 fallback with compiz (0.9.8/bzr) and AWN.
It's quite an enjoyable, solid desktop. Very gnome2-ish, except that i do not use Gnome-panel. Fallback will take a little more effort than cinnamon - to get a decently customized desktop, but for me, it is worth the extra effort ![]()
I also have cinnamon installed, which is pretty decent too. I still prefer compiz over using mutter/muffin - mainly because for the end-user, compiz is a lot more feature packed than GS and/or Cinnamon. (it also has features that i need, that those other options do not). i also experience the odd xrun (proaudio user) when using 'scale' or some other effects (in GS/cinnamon), which is annoying... Compiz also happens to be considerably smoother on my Nvidia hardware. So i stick with what works well for me.
I would actually recommend trying both DEs out ~ you've got nothing to lose and fallback and/or Cinnamon are both very good. it really just depends on what you are looking for.
As for mate - i've never used it and (personally) wouldn't. it is based on a bunch of deprecated gnome2 stuff and from reading threads about it - IMO it is just a hack job that never is going to make real progress or be developed any further. ~ for the most part, it seems like they just hack together workarounds for issues that crop up. I would rather stick with Gnome3 technologies, than to stick with gnome2 when it has been deprecated for over a year, now.
cheerz
Last edited by triplesquarednine (2012-05-02 13:16:11)
Offline
Thanks man! Is there a way I can install just Gnome Fallback and not Gnome Shell since I won't be using that one? Eh, about Cinnamon, I tried it once with Linux Mint, and was dissapointed to see you couldn't drag the application icons from the menu and put them in the panel, like you could with Gnome 2. Or was I doing something wrong? ![]()
Offline
Thanks man! Is there a way I can install just Gnome Fallback and not Gnome Shell since I won't be using that one? Eh, about Cinnamon, I tried it once with Linux Mint, and was dissapointed to see you couldn't drag the application icons from the menu and put them in the panel, like you could with Gnome 2. Or was I doing something wrong?
You can install gnome-fallback without gnome-shell, but then you can't install things like gnome-tweak-tool (as it depends on GS). I initially tried to remove GS last year, when Gnome 3.0 was released. But in the end, i installed GS - i did however, remove other components GS requires (pulseaudio/network manager/etc) At this point GS is completely broken on my system (like i care...lol). Cinnamon and Fallback work great though ![]()
As for the menu thing, i don't know. I don't really use Cinnamon, i basically log into it - whenever there is a significant update. Basically, i am just keeping my eyes on it's development... My guess, is there is probably a way to do that, but i just don't know off hand - you might need to google around for that solution. In Fallback you should be able to do that, but read up in the Archwiki because i think there is a step or two involved in modifying gnome-panel (i can't really remember, since i've never used it with Gnome3).
cheerz
Offline
Ok then! I'll definitely check out Fallback and Cinnamon if I can get that icon thing to work then. Thanks for all the input!
As for mate - i've never used it and (personally) wouldn't. it is based on a bunch of deprecated gnome2 stuff and from reading threads about it - IMO it is just a hack job that never is going to make real progress or be developed any further. ~ for the most part, it seems like they just hack together workarounds for issues that crop up. I would rather stick with Gnome3 technologies, than to stick with gnome2 when it has been deprecated for over a year, now.
That's such a shame. Seemed promising, since it supposedly provided the most Gnome 2 look alike desktop environment. If anything, they should at least make it depend on Gnome 3 components instead of Gnome 2. You'd think they have a head start on that since Gnome 3 Fallback looks similar to Gnome 2.... oh well.
EDIT: WAIT WAIT WAIT just a second. The guy who made it is from Argentina too? Ugh. Of course. mate. MATE. I'm such an idiot!
http://static1.lavozdelinterior.com.ar/ … mate_0.jpg
Should also check that one out to... honor my country and stuff
cheers!
Last edited by mashen (2012-05-02 16:08:16)
Offline
Ok then! I'll definitely check out Fallback and Cinnamon if I can get that icon thing to work then. Thanks for all the input!
That's such a shame. Seemed promising, since it supposedly provided the most Gnome 2 look alike desktop environment. If anything, they should at least make it depend on Gnome 3 components instead of Gnome 2. You'd think they have a head start on that since Gnome 3 Fallback looks similar to Gnome 2....
You 'should' be able to get the icon thing to work, if not in cinnamon - with gnome-panel (in fallback) for sure (i've seen other people's desktop-screenshots with that kind of thing).
As far as Mate is concerned IMO it is a complete waste of time, and not a good solution if one plans to 'move forward' with the technologies used in current DEs. Gnome2 also had quite a few developers/maintainers, most of whom have nothing to do with mate ~ Mate has very few devs. I don't understand why they even bothered, as you mention building on Gnome3 would have been smarter - nothing was stopping them from forking gnome-panel to add functionality. Nothing was stopping them from writing applications for gnome 3 (fallback) to bring certain functionality from gnome 2 to gnome3/mate combo. ~ this is where the Linux Mint people and elementary people have been smart. They recognized that maintaining deprecated technologies that are 'destined for the dustbin' is NOT very smart.
Also, you do know that you can use other panels/docks/etc with gnome 3, right? - i say this because you are not limited to what Cinnamon and/or gnome-panel provides. For example, on my desktop i just use AWN+dockbarX with gnome-pie to provide a more standard menu (presented in a different way);
..and the reality is - Gnome2 is crappier than Gnome3 in many ways, and isn't any more 'customizable' than gnome3. Gnome3 just handles things a little different, and one needs to adjust themselves to how G3 works.
my 2 cents
Offline
you are NOT supposed to post pictures that big in the forums, you should be using a link and/or BBcode
see how mine displays? - a nice small picture that you can click onto to see the full pic?
Last edited by triplesquarednine (2012-05-02 16:02:23)
Offline
you are NOT supposed to post pictures that big in the forums, you should be using a link and/or BBcode
Whoops. Fix'd.
Ah, might still check Mate out, have nothing to lose. I knew about the panels thing, yeah, even tried several out. I just haven't found an alternative one I'm happy with. I was just happy with good ol' Gnome 2, ya know?
..and the reality is - Gnome2 is crappier than Gnome3 in many ways, and isn't any more 'customizable' than gnome3. Gnome3 just handles things a little different, and one needs to adjust themselves to how G3 works.
Never though Gnome 2 was any more customizable than Gnome 3. Actually read a couple of articles and reviews saying Gnome 3 wasn't too customizable... If you mean they added more functionalities to Gnome 3 recently to make it more customizable, I might check it out too. Linux isn't about sticking to one thing for life, it's about the freedom of choice ![]()
Offline
Whoops. Fix'd.
no biggie, just letting you know. ![]()
Ah, might still check Mate out, have nothing to lose. I knew about the panels thing, yeah, even tried several out. I just haven't found an alternative one I'm happy with. I was just happy with good ol' Gnome 2, ya know?
Yeah, i know what you mean. i felt that way at one point, but after using G3 for over a year - i prefer it. for all sorts of reasons which are pretty broad. But yeah, of course you should still check out Mate, if that is what you want to do. My opinions are just that - *my* opinions, right? ![]()
Never though Gnome 2 was any more customizable than Gnome 3. Actually read a couple of articles and reviews saying Gnome 3 wasn't too customizable... If you mean they added more functionalities to Gnome 3 recently to make it more customizable, I might check it out too. Linux isn't about sticking to one thing for life, it's about the freedom of choice
Articles like that were probably fairly old. Gnome 3 (itself) is just as customizable as gnome2. I can give a few of my own examples/preferences;
1. You can use whatever window manager you want with fallback (everything from metacity to openbox to tiling WMs), there are a number of shells/compositors that run on it (unity/compiz/cairocompmgr or even kwin). Gs also has some extensions do do things like proper window tiling features, too.
2. you still have gconf (+ dconf) + .session files - which can completely change how your desktop behaves, what components are required for you desktop, etc.
3. you can have upto six buttons on your window decoration (that i know of).
4. gtk3 themes use CSS which is easier IMO to read/edit
5. gtk3 themes can have 'application specific' theming, if defined. -> ie: i have modifications for nautilus defined in my theme - i don't remember being able to do that as easily in G2
6. Gnome-Shell has many extensions (although i think some still need to be ported to 3.4). through extensions, you can change GS around quite a bit.
The only PITA from my perspective with GS is you are still stuck with 'Activites' overview ~ which i am not interested in and compiz is smoother on my Mvidia hardware. But none of this even matters being as GS is just a shell for G3, as is Compiz or Unity...etc.
so people running gnome3 will have just as drastically different desktops, as we did in Gnome2. But generally, the applications have improved and some of the underlying interfaces have modernized and improved.
That's how i see it anyway ![]()
Last edited by triplesquarednine (2012-05-02 17:23:54)
Offline
That's really cool! Might check it out if I want to customize it to be more work efficient. Although I doubt I'll touch GS if I also have Fallback installed
I agree, the Activities mode thing sucks. The other improvements you mentioned are quite good though. I suppose at least some of them show how much the user input matters. It was because of people's desire to have a more customizable desktop that they made it that way.
Offline