You are not logged in.
Can anyone think of any reason why I would be seeing lower CPU temps (8-10C) using Cinnamon when compared to XFCE? This is running the same applications (Chromium, Pidgin, Terminal, Thunderbird) and CPU usage is roughly equivalent (around 3-4% when idle). My temps hover around 48C on cinnamon and 56C on XFCE.
It just doesn't make a lot of sense to me when they're doing the same THINGS and CPU usage is virtually identical. I've seen my CPU get as cool as 45c on Cinnamon, but never below 50c on xfce. I thought maybe it was xfce compositing, so I turned that off, no change. I even got a little wild and used kwin as my window manager in xfce and that didn't raise or lower the temperatures either, so it doesn't seem to be the way xfce is drawing the desktop, or at least that I can tell.
This is on a laptop, btw. Asus G73jh. To measure the temps I am using xfce's plugin, watching all 4 cores. I can also see all 4 cores on Cinnamon's temperature monitor.
I just thought it was interesting and wondered if anyone else was experiencing the same thing.
Intel 980x| 24GB RAM| Arch + Cinnamon/i3
Intel 2600K| 8GB RAM| Arch + Awesome/XFCE
Intel Q740| 6GB RAM| Arch + XFCE/Cinnamon
AMD Phenom x6 1090T| Ubuntu/Winblowz (gaming)
Offline
Maybe cinnamon is doing some tweaks, see what frequencies are set.
bitcoin: 1G62YGRFkMDwhGr5T5YGovfsxLx44eZo7U
Offline
It's still on an arch base, though, so none of the underlying system actually changes, that's why it's so perplexing to me. I don't have to restart the computer to switch between them, just log out and back in.
Intel 980x| 24GB RAM| Arch + Cinnamon/i3
Intel 2600K| 8GB RAM| Arch + Awesome/XFCE
Intel Q740| 6GB RAM| Arch + XFCE/Cinnamon
AMD Phenom x6 1090T| Ubuntu/Winblowz (gaming)
Offline
I don't think it's XFCE. My temps are consistently around 39C. Could be your hardware or your sensors are not reporting the correct temp? I guess it also depends on how much load your cpu has at the time and all the processes running in the background?
Last edited by w201 (2013-07-03 01:12:38)
Offline
It's still on an arch base, though, so none of the underlying system actually changes, that's why it's so perplexing to me. I don't have to restart the computer to switch between them, just log out and back in.
Yeah, but you are using cinnamon, which is a fork of gnome. I don't know very much about gnome, but I do know that it uses its own configuration method via gconf. From what I understand it is somewhat like the windows registry in how it handles configurations. So maybe there is something inherently different in the way the system runs that underlying system. AFAIK, it would only really be affecting the configurations of X, but that is still a massive amount of potential variables.
The only reason I know that this is the case is because I have run into numerous people on these forums who bitch about their configurations not being respected when using gnome. The most common one is with synaptics in gnome not using /etc/X11/xorg.conf.d/50-synaptics.conf, but I have seen numerous. In fact the nature of the environment you are left with can even be massively changed by the display manager as well. There is a recent thread about someone who ends up with a different PATH when using the DM over starting from the console (startx). I assume though, that you are using the same DM to start both environments, so that is probably not the case. I just wanted to point out that there is a very real possibility of there being much more to the story than thinking that the "uderlying system" is going to be the same.
Offline
baronmax wrote:It's still on an arch base, though, so none of the underlying system actually changes, that's why it's so perplexing to me. I don't have to restart the computer to switch between them, just log out and back in.
Yeah, but you are using cinnamon, which is a fork of gnome. I don't know very much about gnome, but I do know that it uses its own configuration method via gconf. From what I understand it is somewhat like the windows registry in how it handles configurations. So maybe there is something inherently different in the way the system runs that underlying system. AFAIK, it would only really be affecting the configurations of X, but that is still a massive amount of potential variables.
The only reason I know that this is the case is because I have run into numerous people on these forums who bitch about their configurations not being respected when using gnome. The most common one is with synaptics in gnome not using /etc/X11/xorg.conf.d/50-synaptics.conf, but I have seen numerous. In fact the nature of the environment you are left with can even be massively changed by the display manager as well. There is a recent thread about someone who ends up with a different PATH when using the DM over starting from the console (startx). I assume though, that you are using the same DM to start both environments, so that is probably not the case. I just wanted to point out that there is a very real possibility of there being much more to the story than thinking that the "uderlying system" is going to be the same.
As a sidenote, for anyone having trouble getting gnome to recognize their touchpad settings. Instead of using the xorg.conf.d file create a file in your home dir, such as "touchpad_settings.sh". Then put your synclient commands in that file, mark it as executable, and run this command: gsettings set org.gnome.settings-daemon.peripherals.input-devices hotplug-command "/home/put-your-username-here/touchpad_settings.sh"
This will make gnome-settings-daemon always respect the touchpad settings in that file, even after suspend/resume. ![]()
Last edited by bwat47 (2013-07-03 01:52:18)
Offline