You are not logged in.
im looking to submit an AUR package and i have some questions about the maintainer/contributor section.
am i allowed to put a method of contact other than email? (xmmp, matirix, discord, telegram)
how far am i allowed to go with obfuscation? can i create a caesar cypher or something? (including the key ofc)
when forking/using someone else's PKGBUILD as a base, do i credit them just by listing them as "contributor" or should i list them as "contributor/maintainer of original package"?
Offline
Did you read https://wiki.archlinux.org/title/AUR_su … submission ?
(You can extend that note to say "The use of social media contacts makes it difficult for people to contact you.")
Offline
im looking to submit an AUR package and i have some questions about the maintainer/contributor section.
Overall that "section" is all comments that are included as informational and as courtesy and are not strictly required or formalized in any strict manner*. So overall, whatever works for you is fine.
Method of contact: sure, include whatever you want users of the PKGBUILD to use to contact you.
Obfuscation: have at it, go hog wild. But recognize that such obfuscation is a trade-off in increasing your protection against spam while also increasing the burden on users of the PKGBUILD. As you increase obfuscation the bulk of that increase goes to the latter category (i.e., a lot more annoying, not much more security).
When forking a PKGBUILD crediting the previous author as a contributor is a courtesy. In every major jurisdiction that I am aware of, a PKGBUILD would not be considered sufficient for any copyright protection and thus there is no legal (and arguably no ethical) need to credit anyone for it. But it is seen as a courtesy to acknowledge their work if your PKGBUILD draws heavily on something someone else already made. Frankly PKGBUILDs with dozens of lines of these credits due to a long history of modification is silly when the current PKGBUILD no longer bears any resemblance at all to the one used by the people being credited: Theseus's name can eventually be removed from the ship.
*EDIT: I believe much of the above-linked wiki section is new since I last read up on it. I guess some of this has been formalized in a fairly strict manner. But that's pretty silly if you ask me.
Last edited by Trilby (Yesterday 16:58:39)
"UNIX is simple and coherent" - Dennis Ritchie; "GNU's Not Unix" - Richard Stallman
Offline
https://wiki.archlinux.org/index.php?ti … did=783575 - 2023
https://wiki.archlinux.org/index.php?ti … did=575345 from 2019 didn't have the -vcs/-bin convention formalized (which seems rather useful to distinguish alternatives?)
https://wiki.archlinux.org/index.php?ti … did=582291 from September 2019 replaced "no binaries!" w/ "use the -bin suffix"
Offline
I appreciate your responses. I am pretty deterred away from having email as the only (or primary) was of contacting me. i tend to need to spend a while sorting through my email (honestly, I would have probably missed the notification for this thread until later tomorrow if not for pure luck) and it would be ideal if users who needed to directly communicate with me could contact me through some form of instant messaging (I mean, it's called instant for a reason xP).
I have to ask, would I get in trouble or something for not providing an email? additionally, if I absolutely had to provide an email, could I also provide IM contacts and note them as preferred?
(also sorry for asking so many questions, I like to be sure about what I'm doing before I get into things)
Last edited by TipsyTheCat (Today 04:49:32)
Offline
on a tangent: speaking of IMs, looks like the messaging section of profiles here hasn't been updated in a very long time. all but jabber (now xmmp) don't exist anymore. (well, technically a "Microsoft account" could be used to message someone still, but I don't think anyone is gonna use teams (willingly), and you'd have to be insane to use Xbox live as an im outside of.. an Xbox. xP
Offline
A lot of Arch's infrastructure is indeed dated. It needs both someone to write the update and just as importantly someone with commit privileges to review and commit it or you get merge requests sitting for years for example.
Last edited by loqs (Today 06:19:30)
Offline
i tend to need to spend a while sorting through my email (honestly, I would have probably missed the notification for this thread
Get
* a better mail service (server side filtering)
* a better mail user agent (mutt)
* different mail accounts for different purposes
I mean, it's called instant for a reason xP
You don't sleep?
would I get in trouble or something for not providing an email? additionally, if I absolutely had to provide an email, could I also provide IM contacts and note them as preferred?
Providing a mail contact will be expected - even if not compulsory users might be (irrationally, mal-actors will just use a throwaway account) suspicious about the package.
Other comments are free-form, you can put there whatever you want.
The non-negotiable parts wrt
forking/using someone else's PKGBUILD as a base
are that your package must (be useful to others and) not be a redundancy, ie. don't upload derivative packages as means to bugfix others ("i didn't like the compiler settings" or stuff like that)
Offline
got it, thank you <3
Offline