You are not logged in.
Pages: 1
With CachyOS distributing a very locked down kernel, namely the EACv2 enabled kernel containing many proprietary and non-GPL modules, especially the nvidia and zfs modules, along with secureboot signed keys, as someone helping to maintain the Install Arch on ZFS Root, this has raised some obvious red flags with me, and raises a question, is it even legal to distribute this kernel at all?
My arguments:
1. The inclusion of a pre-built ZFS kernel module violates the GPL and CDDL licenses both. To get around this with the wiki page I help maintain instructions to pre-build binaries for the custom iso, and then compile on-site packages later via dkms to avoid distribution licensing issues. A warning on the wiki is also provided not to redistribute these images.
2. The Nvidia, Broadcom, and Realtek modules are proprietary. While this is generally accepted as normal, it has been standing practice to use an onsite built package rather than a direct from distribution package due to the fact bugs in drivers can exist requiring updates regularly outside the kernel stream. These drivers are also distributed by their respective providers under their own EULAs, licenses, and terms and conditions.
Could Cachy be forced to take this kernel down if it's found to be violating multiple licenses, and what penalties could they actually face, if any?
Offline
Pages: 1