You are not logged in.
Hi,
Which of those two office suits is recommended for KDE environment.
My needs are word processing and spreadsheet mainly with both English and Hebrew support.
Thanks
Best regards,
Michael Badt
Offline
Try them both out. See which one you like.
There's no such thing as a stupid question, but there sure are a lot of inquisitive idiots !
Offline
I have no experience with Calligra, but I gather they have very similar capabilities.
I would not be surprised if Calligra is better integrated with other KDE tools ... as they are packaged by the same people. But on the flip side, I suspect it is easier to get (informal / forum based) support for libreoffice as I suspect there is a wider user base.
So perhaps those pros and cons will give something to consider - but as Inxsible points out, only you can decide which fits you best by trying them both ... or just pick one: if you don't have any peculiar needs, either one should work well.
"UNIX is simple and coherent" - Dennis Ritchie; "GNU's Not Unix" - Richard Stallman
Online
I recently installed the Calligra suite to check it out. Two situations made me not want to use it though, almost instantly.
-The fact that you can't control the color of the document background : it seems that you can't avoid the default white background (while I am used to very dark color schemes, and this really hurt my eyes). I hope I did not miss something there.
-The fact that although it can open .doc files it does not save in this format (generally this should not be a problem, but it can be a serious one if it is/gets work related...).
As you can see I did not get to see what it has to offer at all, so I cannot have a well based opinion. I can admit that the two situations mentioned above are not "serious" when one has to decide whether to use an office suite or not, but for me they were deal breakers. Shame because there is nice software in the suite...
As far as libreoffice integration in KDE is concerned, you can find all you need in the wiki.
Now there sits a man with an open mind. You can feel the draft from here...
Groucho Marx
Offline
for me opening but not being able to save in .doc, .docx formats is the deal breaker, because everyone around here are so used to pirated windows and office, so it's the "standard" around here, shame! Obviously this is not calligras fault at all, but it would be nice to be able to do it.
Laptop: LG LM70 Express Kernel: 3.14.2-1-ARCH
CPU: Intel Pentium M processor @1.86GHz Hard Drive: 80G
Video: Mobility Radeon X600 X Driver: xf86-video-ati
Memory Size: 1.5G + zramswap: 384M + swap: 3G
Offline
Thanks all!
Best regards,
Michael Badt
Offline
I use more and more calligra suite, mainly words, sheets, now recently karbon and flow and I'm really impressed BUT about all the wonderfull tools inside but "is not libre-office", libreoffice is a mature project, with a big community and support, and calligra is growing step by step, with big performance, I had a lot of documents open at the same time, with 3 diff apps of calligra and still light in memory and cpu consomption. The integration of calligra in KDE is there, no question about that. If you have the time and motivation about a new project like calligra take the time to discover it, even if some times I need use libreoffice for some reasons.. good choice
KF5 & Plasma5 (git versions) - Awesome WM
ASUS Sabertooth 990FX - AMD FX8350 - ATI Radeon HD 7970
[testing] repo
Offline
for me opening but not being able to save in .doc, .docx formats is the deal breaker, because everyone around here are so used to pirated windows and office, so it's the "standard" around here, shame! Obviously this is not calligras fault at all, but it would be nice to be able to do it.
Things aren't going to change by just accepting it. I hate that people send around .doc files especially in cases where a pdf or plain text would be just fine. Since I hate it, I don't do it! Let the others complain...they're the problem, not me. ![]()
Offline
@jakobcreutzfeldt:
Yes I know it sucks, but many people doesn't really know how to use a computer or doesn't care (I have even recieved images INSIDE .doc files, why not just send the images?).
The problem is that I need to be able to send those formats because in school for me it's a must, I have tried sending them odf documments and at first it was ok, they didn't even noticed, I mean they did notice, but tried to open it anyways and it worked for them under windows, but since win* office kinda sucks also in its support for odf, I would get from time to time, complains.
Anyway fortunately I can still do it with libreoffice, but now calligra suite has taken control of one of my computers with 256M of ram (with zramswap) and even with all the dependencies it pulls Its still light on ram and better than abiword and gnucash for me, with the plus of a light presentation software, wich doesnt have a gtk counterpart yet.
(I'm thinking on ditching lxde and use kde with openbox (or goomwwm), and a light setup and apps (and the other 256M ram module), kde is getting really light (compared to itself) and responsive! I have it already installed but hadn't the time to switch completely yet in this pc because of school, still im impressed!)
Laptop: LG LM70 Express Kernel: 3.14.2-1-ARCH
CPU: Intel Pentium M processor @1.86GHz Hard Drive: 80G
Video: Mobility Radeon X600 X Driver: xf86-video-ati
Memory Size: 1.5G + zramswap: 384M + swap: 3G
Offline